Every fan of Star Trek: The Original Series has compiled a list of their favorite third-season episodes, and “That Which Survives” is on ours. We think it needs to be there because it has a lot going for it: a “beat the clock” story that finds the Enterprise racing uncontrolled across the cosmos, a landing party stranded on a strange world, and a beautiful but deadly alien woman that’s able to make herself disappear in a thin vertical line. Since today is the 50th anniversary of the original broadcast of this episode, we thought we’d explore its origins, the development of a few of its characters, and one of its set pieces.
But please, do not be afraid as you read this article. We are here for you, StarTrek.com reader.
The story for “That Which Survives” was provided by Dorothy (D.C.) Fontana via her March 8, 1968 outline entitled “Survival.” Even though Fontana eventually requested that a pseudonym be used for her on-screen writing credit (specifically, she used Michael Richards, because, reportedly, she was unhappy with the rewrites as the outline progressed to shooting script), many of her ideas survived to the finished episode. Major differences between her outline and what ended up on the screen include:
- The landing party that investigated the outpost (and planetoid in the outline) originally consisted of Kirk, McCoy, Chekov and Dawson. Chekov’s part eventually was given to Sulu and Dawson became D’Amato (a change made right before filming began).
- Sulu stayed on board the Enterprise to help with the mystery of how the ship was suddenly transported across space.
- Speaking of the Enterprise’s mysterious transportation, the outline provides an explanation as to why the ship was reassembled in an outphase condition (referred to as an incorrect molecular structure in the outline). Simply, the outpost had trouble transporting something as large as the Enterprise and it made an error.
- The jeopardy caused by the ship’s uncontrolled acceleration, via the sabotage to the emergency bypass control, was not present in the outline. In fact, the Enterprise’s trip back to the outpost was fairly routine – and mundane.
- The alien that eventually became Losira was a talon-ed energy image/being in the outline. This being could absorb energy from phaser beams and heat, and it used its talons to rip apart Dawson.
- McCoy was captured by the talon-ed energy entity in the outline and replaced by a metalized version. The real McCoy was held prisoner in the computer cave.
- At the conclusion of the outline, Kirk and Chekov located the real McCoy and escaped from the talon-ed energy being – which had been generated by the outpost’s computer when it got distracted by the arrival of the Enterprise. Later, on the ship, Kirk informed Starfleet that the planetoid should be destroyed or declared off-limits, and then the Enterprise dropped warning buoys around it.
Character and Set Piece Development
As the story for “That Which Survives” evolved from its initial outline to its shooting draft (which was the September 20, 1968 revised final draft, teleplay by John Meredyth Lucas and story by D. C. Fontana), several of its guest characters also evolved, as well as one of its set pieces. For example, as mentioned above, Lt. Dawson in the original outline became Lt. D’Amato in the episode (and played by Arthur Batanides). Here are a few other interesting changes.
Above: Dr. M’Benga (Booker Bradshaw) made his first TOS appearance in the second-season episode, “A Private Little War.” Interestingly, he was added to “That Which Survives” fairly late in the process, in fact, only a few days before filming commenced. In the first draft of the script (story by D.C. Fontana and teleplay by John Meredyth Lucas, September 9, 1968) the doctor was a man named M’Boya. In the intermediate drafts, the character was eliminated completely and his dialogue given to Nurse Christine Chapel (Majel Barrett-Roddenberry).
Above: Lt. Rahda’s character – played by Naomi Pollack – was developed essentially by combining two male lieutenants that appeared in the first draft. Incidentally, Pollack’s first appearance in TOS was as a Native American in the third-season episode, “The Paradise Syndrome.”
Above: The talon-ed energy image/being in the story outline was replaced with Osira the Thalassan in the first draft. In subsequent versions, including the shooting draft, the image/being became Losira the Kalandan (and played by Lee Meriwether).
Above: In the finished episode, the cube-shaped computer on the outpost was suspended from the ceiling of the “brain room.” However, in the shooting script, it was supposed to sit in the middle of it. As seen in the episode, the computer had translucent panels on which pulsating/rotating lights were projected. The final effect was reminiscent of one generated by a rotating lamp shade.
And with that, we come to the end of this piece. Remember: although this article is transitory, the beauty of this episode is not. Until next time.
David Tilotta is a professor at North Carolina State University and Curt McAloney is a graphic artist residing in Minnesota. Together, they work on startrekhistory.com. Their book, Star Trek: Lost Scenes, was released in August 2018 by Titan Books and it’s filled with hundreds of carefully curated, never-before-seen color photos that are used to chronicle the making of the original series, reassemble deleted scenes left on the cutting-room floor, and showcase bloopers from the first pilot through the last episode. They can be contacted at firstname.lastname@example.org and email@example.com.