Ezri Janeway GROUP: Members POSTS: 2510 |
Report this
Jul. 01 2011, 9:38 am
Quote: DS9TREK @ Jul. 01 2011, 6:39 am | >
>Most people support the government on pensions and it'll get into more trouble if it backs down. Why should I work to age 68 or 70 so my taxes can fund public sector workers retirement at age 60 on a pension several times higher than my own?
>Public sector workers striking is waste of time anyway, if the private sector strikes, the employer worries about profits. When public workers strike, government has saved some money.
> |
Have to say I can see both sides and I cant see a huge Uturn or anything like that. But silently accepting all the Gov is suggesting would be a Very Bad Thing, so while we wont get them to change their minds on everything, seeing an angry nation is going to encourage them to tread very carefully as time goes on. A very good thing considering Conservative history. Not mentioning Lib Dems as they have mostly been as good as a chocolate fire guard. 
"Let me see if Ive got this straight. You're risking the ship, the crew, and the mission on the assumptions that Helkara and Leishman are engineering geniuses, Tharp is a piloting savant, our transporter chief can work miracles, and the Breen are unwilling to sacrifice themselves in a kamikaze attack?"
"Yup."
"Damn I LOVE this job."
|
DutchPicard GROUP: Members POSTS: 283 |
Report this
Jul. 01 2011, 9:43 am
Yeah they changed pension age here too from 65 to 67, no protest no nothing 
|
Ezri Janeway GROUP: Members POSTS: 2510 |
Report this
Jul. 01 2011, 9:52 am
Quote: DutchPicard @ Jul. 01 2011, 9:43 am | >
>Yeah they changed pension age here too from 65 to 67, no protest no nothing
> |
I think its gone up here by 8 years. Not sure but its a fair chunk. That and for some their pension will actually be less than what they had been origionally told it would be. So from a personal perspective of all those affected it understandable there a little miffed. Its also on top of the Gov doing their best to destroy the NHS (again), people loosing jobs left right and centre, the cost of living rising steeply while wages are at a freeze and the Gov doing all this to reduce a debt they have so far failed to reduce even slightly.
And I havent even mentioned housing, social care or student fees.
All in the name of reducing the defecit. 
"Let me see if Ive got this straight. You're risking the ship, the crew, and the mission on the assumptions that Helkara and Leishman are engineering geniuses, Tharp is a piloting savant, our transporter chief can work miracles, and the Breen are unwilling to sacrifice themselves in a kamikaze attack?"
"Yup."
"Damn I LOVE this job."
|
DutchPicard GROUP: Members POSTS: 283 |
Report this
Jul. 01 2011, 9:54 am
Yeah I blame the baby boom generation :
|
Ghostmojo GROUP: Members POSTS: 1824 |
Report this
Jul. 01 2011, 10:19 am
Quote: DS9TREK @ Jul. 01 2011, 6:33 am | >
>Greece's problems won't ever be seen in the US. Corruption is massive - you have to pay bribes all the time. For example: you're expected to pass €200 under the table if you want a passport. Because of the corruption and bribery official wages are much lower than they should be - IT workers earn 50% less than elsewhere - denying government crucial revenue from income taxes.
>Greece's next problem is people getting out of paying their taxes through every trick in the book. In Greece you only pay tax on your home if it's finished, so they leave a small patch of the roof undone.
>Third, Greece is stuck in an artificial currency that's worth about as much as monopoly money.
>And finally, Greeks are just plain lazy.
> |
Well I'm not sure I could condone your final remark as representative of the whole nation - but broadly speaking you are correct in your analysis.
However, the Euro should not be judged as monopoly money. It is weakened by Irish, Portuguese, Spanish and Greek involvement. It is strengthened by German, French, Dutch, Scandinavian and Italian presence. It was a mistake to mix these differing economies.
It breaks my heart what is happening in Greece and worries me where it is all going. This country (and particularly Athens) was the cradle of western democracy (and civilisation). Without Greece, and more specifically 5th Century BC Athens - the world would be a very different place.
However, early 21st Century AD Athens is a quiet different place.
Greece is bankrupt and has been for years. The billions of Euros they are getting as a bailout package is to help them repay debts they have already incurred! The poor old French and German banks are effectively registered charitable donors when it come to the Hellenes.
They are most unlikely to ever see their money again.
Greece is run on alice in wonderland economics. It has a public sector three times the size it needs. These people are reasonably well-paid considering how little they actually do. And anyway their wages are being paid not by other Greek tax-payers - but by the poor old German taxpayer. The mind boggles...
Much the same can be said for Ireland, Portugal and possibly/probably Spain.
These countries just are not productive enough and pay themselves way too much. They think because they are part of the EU they deserve the same standard of living as the Germans, Dutch or Danes - all of whom are productive nations with sound economic structures.
Who knows where it will all end? In the case of Greece - if it does all go tits-up - I hope it won't mean a return to the period of the Colonels which some of you may just be old enough to remember ...
to boldy go where no man has gone before
|
FleetAdmiral_BamBam GROUP: Members POSTS: 44386 |
Report this
Jul. 01 2011, 10:32 am
Quote: Ghostmojo @ Jul. 01 2011, 10:19 am | Quote: DS9TREK @ Jul. 01 2011, 6:33 am | >
>
>Greece's problems won't ever be seen in the US. Corruption is massive - you have to pay bribes all the time. For example: you're expected to pass €200 under the table if you want a passport. Because of the corruption and bribery official wages are much lower than they should be - IT workers earn 50% less than elsewhere - denying government crucial revenue from income taxes.
>Greece's next problem is people getting out of paying their taxes through every trick in the book. In Greece you only pay tax on your home if it's finished, so they leave a small patch of the roof undone.
>Third, Greece is stuck in an artificial currency that's worth about as much as monopoly money.
>And finally, Greeks are just plain lazy.
> |
Well I'm not sure I could condone your final remark as representative of the whole nation - but broadly speaking you are correct in your analysis.
However, the Euro should be judged as monopoly money. It is weakened by Irish, Portuguese, Spanish and Greek involvement. It is strengthened by German, French, Dutch, Scandinavian and Italian presence. It was a mistake to mix these differing economies.
It breaks my heart what is happening in Greece and worries me where it is all going. This country (and particularly Athens) was the cradle of western democracy (and civilisation). Without Greece, and more specifically 5th Century BC Athens - the world would be a very different place.
However, early 21st Century AD Athens is a quiet different place.
Greece is bankrupt and has been for years. The billions of Euros they are getting as a bailout package is to help them repay debts they have already incurred! The poor old French and German banks are effectively registered charitable donors when it come to the Hellenes.
They are most unlikely to ever see their money again.
Greece is run on alice in wonderland economics. It has a public sector three times the size it needs. These people are reasonably well-paid considering how little they actually do. And anyway their wages are being paid not by other Greek tax-payers - but by the poor old German taxpayer. The mind boggles...
Much the same can be said for Ireland, Portugal and possibly/probably Spain.
These countries just are not productive enough and pay themselves way too much. They think because they are part of the EU they deserve the same standard of living as the Germans, Dutch or Danes - all of whom are productive nations with sound economic structures.
Who knows where it will all end? In the case of Greece - if it does all go tits-up - I hope it won't mean a return to the period of the Colonels which some of you may just be old enough to remember ...
|
I've never liked the idea of the Euro. And now some want to make it even worse with single global currency.
|
Ghostmojo GROUP: Members POSTS: 1824 |
Report this
Jul. 01 2011, 10:33 am
Quote: Ezri Janeway @ Jul. 01 2011, 4:58 am | >
>While violence is no answer I cant blame the Greeks for coming out in protest.
>Looks like the UK has finally, at long last, decided to start protesting too. We had a spate of students and lecturers coming out over the fees hike, but a lot of ordinary working folk either didnt care or said 'tough'. I said, months back "You'll feel differently when they freeze your wage, make you redundant, up the retirement age and come after your pension". It took the latter to gets people out in protest, just yesterday. But, typically, many unions are stalling strikes while others are going ahead so its a mixed message. Come autumn more will be out and it might not be too late to make a difference, but Im not holding my breath.
> |
Who are you talking about though?
I don't support the teachers' position - and many teachers don't either (I have several friends in that profession).
In order to have a repesentative strike you need more than 50% vote from a more than 50% turnout of membership - which let's be frank never happens.
The Union leaders piss me off big style.
I agree with them about the rich bankers who have screwed the economy big style - and if I had my way many of the senior banking 'offenders' would be in prison; but I completely disagree with their views on pensions etc.
They are talking about their own members. This is a section of society - not the general workforce.
What the hell is so special about the public sector?
Take two examples Mr Smith and Mr Jones who live next door to each other. One works in the public sector - the other in the private sector:
Mr Smith gets up, has breakfast, goes to work, does his (public sector) job, comes home, relaxes, watches TV, goes to bed etc.
Mr Jones gets up, has breakfast, goes to work, does his (private sector) job, comes home, relaxes, watches TV, goes to bed etc.
What is the bloody difference?
There is none. They both have jobs. Period. They both work for a living - and during times of recession and austerity everybody should be glad if they are still in work - especially the public sector lot. My own experience of the public sector in the UK is that the standard of the workfocre is of a lower calibre than the private sector. Public sector workers are often not nearly as capable and many wouldn't actually get jobs in the real productive economy.
So why do we (including me) have to pay towards their pensions when they don't pay towards ours (and mine) in the private sector?
It doesn't add up - isn't fair - and not only should be reformed, but in all but a very special cases, tax-payer subsidised public sector pensions should be abolished in my view.
_____________________________________________
BTW in my other previous post I mean to say the Euro should not be judged that way. The Euro is merely what the US Dollar was in the late 1800s (and still is). It is a common currency to cover a large geographic market. It was a good idea but is failing because of its weakest constituents. Take out the weak economies and it would be a very strong currency. Any currency superseding the Deutschmark, French Franc, Dutch Guilder etc, is a money unit to be reckoned with.
And I say all of that as a Brit who is still happy with the £ sterling ...
to boldy go where no man has gone before
|
caltrek2 GROUP: Members POSTS: 2654 |
Report this
Jul. 01 2011, 8:15 pm
Quote: FleetAdmiral_BamBam @ Jul. 01 2011, 9:02 am | Quote: caltrek2 @ Jul. 01 2011, 5:48 am | >
>
>In Greece, I get the feeling that the causes are a kind of all of the above type answer. Countries that spend well beyond their means while at the same time failing to collect taxes from the extremely wealthy within their borders are going to be prone to this type of crisis. Further, we shouldn't lose sight of what precipitated the world wide economic meltdown, the dramatic burst of the way overextended housing bubble. A comparative handful of insiders benefited enormously at the beginning of that bubble, and now the rest of society has to suffer by the fallout from the situation from which they benefited. No wonder there is a kind of unfocused resentment and anger in countries like Greece.
>Sure, maybe they should have focused on a more responsible spending plan, but that mistake should be seen within an overall context.
>
> |
I definitely agree with you that governments are spending way too much, but why is stealing other people's money the answer?
|
Stealing and taxation are two different things. You can equate them all you want if you wish, doesn't make them identical.
A hundred years or so ago these disturbance in some parts of the world would have led to an otherthrow of the government and lining up the greedy sons of beaches who had the most wealth up against the wall where they would have been promptly shot. Nowadays, we've gone to the other extreme, the extremely wealthy who got that way manipulaitng one rule of society or another are lauded as fearless entrepenuers, and anybody who dare to question the good that they have supposedly bestowed is labeled a heretic against the capitalist religion. So even an advocacy of a five or ten percent increase in the tax rate for the rich is thought of as an unjust manifestation of hatred toward those poor innocent souls.
Lining them up against the wall may not have been right, but letting them rob us blind as a supplication to the god of capitalism also strike me as a bit extreme. At the very least, lets try and think clearly about what has gone done, particularly in regards to the lending sector of our societies.
As Americans, we sometimes suffer from too much pluribus and not enough unum.
- Arthur Schelsinger, Jr.
|
FleetAdmiral_BamBam GROUP: Members POSTS: 44386 |
Report this
Jul. 01 2011, 9:07 pm
Quote: caltrek2 @ Jul. 01 2011, 8:15 pm | Quote: FleetAdmiral_BamBam @ Jul. 01 2011, 9:02 am | Quote: caltrek2 @ Jul. 01 2011, 5:48 am | >
>
>
>In Greece, I get the feeling that the causes are a kind of all of the above type answer. Countries that spend well beyond their means while at the same time failing to collect taxes from the extremely wealthy within their borders are going to be prone to this type of crisis. Further, we shouldn't lose sight of what precipitated the world wide economic meltdown, the dramatic burst of the way overextended housing bubble. A comparative handful of insiders benefited enormously at the beginning of that bubble, and now the rest of society has to suffer by the fallout from the situation from which they benefited. No wonder there is a kind of unfocused resentment and anger in countries like Greece.
>Sure, maybe they should have focused on a more responsible spending plan, but that mistake should be seen within an overall context.
>
> |
I definitely agree with you that governments are spending way too much, but why is stealing other people's money the answer?
|
Stealing and taxation are two different things. You can equate them all you want if you wish, doesn't make them identical.
A hundred years or so ago these disturbance in some parts of the world would have led to an otherthrow of the government and lining up the greedy sons of beaches who had the most wealth up against the wall where they would have been promptly shot. Nowadays, we've gone to the other extreme, the extremely wealthy who got that way manipulaitng one rule of society or another are lauded as fearless entrepenuers, and anybody who dare to question the good that they have supposedly bestowed is labeled a heretic against the capitalist religion. So even an advocacy of a five or ten percent increase in the tax rate for the rich is thought of as an unjust manifestation of hatred toward those poor innocent souls.
Lining them up against the wall may not have been right, but letting them rob us blind as a supplication to the god of capitalism also strike me as a bit extreme. At the very least, lets try and think clearly about what has gone done, particularly in regards to the lending sector of our societies.
|
stealing and taxing CAN and SHOULD be two different things, but when taxation is not equal - when taxation is used to penalyze a certain group - taxation is used to steal. Just because someone has more than you do doesn't mean that they robbed us blind. They earned their money and we all have the same opportunities to do the same (at least if the government regulations get out of our way.)
Now, are there people that are corrupt and use government to ensure their success? Of course - look at GE, etc. to coerce goverment officials to pass laws to help them and hurt their competitors. That's wrong and should be addressed. But.... those are two different subjects.
|