BashirBonesBeverly GROUP: Members POSTS: 2003 |
Report this
Jun. 18 2009, 6:53 pm
| Quote (Vortaborg @ June 18 2009, 3:51 pm) | [quote=BashirBonesBeverly,June 14 2009, 11:18 pm]| Quote | | um, the changelings don't trust solids. ¿why would they? ¿because Odo tells them to? ¿pfft, they aren't going to listen to him. ¿The war only ended because ODO agreed to go back to the link to cure them all. ¿How did they get infected in the first place? ¿Oh yeah, solids made them sick. ¿Who did they directly infect? ¿Oh yeah, it was Odo...the person telling them to trust solids. ¿Odo was betrayed by the solids himself. |
No offense, but I really think you need to watch the episode again. The female changeling says that she won't surrender because it would be a sign of weakness, for the solids to cross into the Gamma Quadrant and destroy the great link. Then after Odo LINKS with her (not tells her, linking is something totally different) she not only surrenders but agrees to go on trial for what she's done. Would you do this for something you didn't think was your fault and was totally justified?
And then Odo tells them he needs to go back, not only to cure his people but to teach them what he learned by living with solids. He says so. |
I've seen it far too many times to count my friend. In return for the surrender, Odo agrees to go back and heal the link. That is the only condition of the surrender. There is nothing that should lead you to believe they suddenly trust solids. It has nothing to do with whether or not she believes the Dominion is right or wrong, it's all about curing her race from becoming extinct. And as you say, Odo wants to go back to teach them about the solids. Why would he try to teach his people to trust solids if as you say they already trust them? please
|
Vortaborg GROUP: Members POSTS: 126 |
Report this
Jun. 21 2009, 11:12 am
| Quote (BashirBonesBeverly @ June 18 2009, 6:53 pm) | |
Because he only linked with that one changeling, he had to go back and teach the rest of the changelings., they aren't telepathically linked. Clearly she thought what she was doing was wrong. She agreed to go on trial (we never saw that trial though) If Odo wanted to cure his people all he would need to do is go through the wormhole and do it. Not link with the female changeling. Too bad Ronald Moore doesn't answer questions anymore. So, we couldn't ask him if the changelings now trust solids and that's why she agreed to stop the war. How much would you be willing to risk for it, if he did? I'd bet it against you.  Remember the dialogue: Female changeling: I don't have your faith in the solids. Odo: Maybe I can change your mind Then he links with her and they agree to surrender.
|
BashirBonesBeverly GROUP: Members POSTS: 2003 |
Report this
Jun. 22 2009, 2:34 am
| Quote (Vortaborg @ June 21 2009, 11:12 am) | Because he only linked with that one changeling, he had to go back and teach the rest of the changelings., they aren't telepathically linked. Clearly she thought what she was doing was wrong. She agreed to go on trial (we never saw that trial though) If Odo wanted to cure his people all he would need to do is go through the wormhole and do it. Not link with the female changeling.
Too bad Ronald Moore doesn't answer questions anymore. So, we couldn't ask him if the changelings now trust solids and that's why she agreed to stop the war. How much would you be willing to risk for it, if he did? I'd bet it against you. 
Remember the dialogue:
Female changeling: I don't have your faith in the solids.
Odo: Maybe I can change your mind
Then he links with her and they agree to surrender. |
ronald moore and the others have signed off on the relaunch book series, meaning they approve of the content. the books show that the founders, including the one who surrendered do not trust solids. | Quote | | Clearly she thought what she was doing was wrong. |
Yes, clearly not surrendering and causing the extinction of her people would be wrong in her eyes. Avoiding extinction is much more important than winning a war.
|
OtakuJo GROUP: Members POSTS: 16257 |
Report this
Jun. 23 2009, 2:25 am
| Quote (Vortaborg @ June 18 2009, 3:51 pm) | [quote=BashirBonesBeverly,June 14 2009, 11:18 pm]| Quote | | um, the changelings don't trust solids. ¿why would they? ¿because Odo tells them to? ¿pfft, they aren't going to listen to him. ¿The war only ended because ODO agreed to go back to the link to cure them all. ¿How did they get infected in the first place? ¿Oh yeah, solids made them sick. ¿Who did they directly infect? ¿Oh yeah, it was Odo...the person telling them to trust solids. ¿Odo was betrayed by the solids himself. |
No offense, but I really think you need to watch the episode again. The female changeling says that she won't surrender because it would be a sign of weakness, for the solids to cross into the Gamma Quadrant and destroy the great link. Then after Odo LINKS with her (not tells her, linking is something totally different) she not only surrenders but agrees to go on trial for what she's done. |
Not to side with anyone in this debate -- but simply to add something extra -- During the Dominion occupation of DS9, there is also a moment when the female founder tells Weyoun, getting Odo to rejoin the great link is far more important than winning the war. "More important than the Alpha Quadrant itself", I believe is her words. So from that perspective, it stands to reason that if Odo agrees to rejoin the Link should she end the war -- a war the Dominion is pretty well bound to lose at this point anyway -- then she would see that as a reasonable deal.
|
Vortaborg GROUP: Members POSTS: 126 |
Report this
Jun. 26 2009, 6:30 pm
|
|
|
|
|
|
| | | | | | border="0" align="center" width="95%" cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0">>>Quote (BashirBonesBeverly @ June 22 2009, 2:34 am) | > id="QUOTE"> border="0" align="center" width="95%" cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0">>>Quote (Vortaborg @ June 21 2009, 11:12 am)> id="QUOTE"> border="0" align="center" width="95%" cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0">>>Quote (BashirBonesBeverly @ June 18 2009, 6:53 pm)> id="QUOTE">
Because he only linked with that one changeling, he had to go back and teach the rest of the changelings., they aren't telepathically linked. Clearly she thought what she was doing was wrong. She agreed to go on trial (we never saw that trial though) If Odo wanted to cure his people all he would need to do is go through the wormhole and do it. Not link with the female changeling.
Too bad Ronald Moore doesn't answer questions anymore. So, we couldn't ask him if the changelings now trust solids and that's why she agreed to stop the war. How much would you be willing to risk for it, if he did? I'd bet it against you. 
Remember the dialogue:
Female changeling: I don't have your faith in the solids.
Odo: Maybe I can change your mind
Then he links with her and they agree to surrender.
ronald moore and the others have signed off on the relaunch book series, meaning they approve of the content.
the books show that the founders, including the one who surrendered do not trust solids.
border="0" align="center" width="95%" cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0">>>Quote > id="QUOTE">the books show that the founders, including the one who surrendered do not trust solids.
And novels aren't canon. Unless, well have they stated these ones are? At least Gene used to say they weren't.
|
sjsharp2004 GROUP: Members POSTS: 1700 |
Report this
Jun. 26 2009, 9:47 pm
| Quote (exodus201 @ June 16 2009, 2:12 am) | | Quote (Vortaborg @ June 14 2009, 1:26 pm) | Now, that they through Odo have learned to trust solids. Will they disband the dominion and give Jem'Hadar and Vorta free will? Join the Federation perhaps?
Also, I wondered why it was only solids they distrusted. Remember in the Dauphin (a TNG episode) there was another race of shapeshifters called the Allasamorph that held (at least Anye (sp?) did) that any race other than their own was dangerous, which would probably include other shapeshifting races. If changelings assumed because some solids were dangerous to them then why didn't changelings also assume if they had an encounter with another race that wasn't a solid, or changeling or that they could also be dangerous?
And lastly. I wondered if they didn't trust a solid if they could link with them. Yes, I know solids can't link. But, a changeling transformed solid Odo back into a changeling, so they could transform one into a changeling to link with him/her. Although, wasn't there a mention that Odo may not have been made into an 100% solid by the founders? |
I don't think they learned to trust solids, I just think they signed a treaty like the Federation did with the Romulans. ¿You don't enter our space and we won't invade yours. |
I think you're right exodus
|
Vortaborg GROUP: Members POSTS: 126 |
Report this
Jun. 26 2009, 10:37 pm
You remember the Dauphin with the shape shifting Allasamorph Species? The Governess Allasmorph had the exact same philosophy toward non-shape shifters that the the founders have.
|
OtakuJo GROUP: Members POSTS: 16257 |
Report this
Jun. 26 2009, 10:38 pm
...Besides much of the idea behind Odo returning to the Gamma Q. was that he could teach the other Founders to trust solids more -- which presumably implies that this is something they have not learnt yet.
|
Vorta_the_point GROUP: Members POSTS: 624 |
Report this
Jun. 27 2009, 3:37 pm
It's also worth noting that the major reason the Female Shapeshifter was refusing to surrender was that it would be seen as a sign of weakness which would lead to the Alpha Quadrant powers invading the Gamma Quadrant and destroying the Great Link.
When Odo tried to persuade her verbally that this wouldn't happen, she refused to believe him as she "didn't share his faith in the solids" - however, after linking, she no longer seemed to have this objection, and this can't have been soley due to Odo's agreement to return to the Link as his return would have no bearing on whether or not the Alpha Quadrant would invade and destroy the Founders; it seems that at the very least he did in fact successfully persuade her that the Alpha Quadrant would not invade.
I doubt that Odo would be able to change the Great Link's anti-solid mindset overnight, but from his at least partial success with the Female Changeling, I suspect that he would most probably begin a gradual attitude shift, one that would be spurred on even more as time progresses and the Founders realise that the Alpha Quadrant really hasn't invaded them.
|
Quantumflux01 GROUP: Members POSTS: 428 |
Report this
May. 12 2010, 4:43 pm
Panic: the Vorta will follow the founders no matter what. But the Jem'Hader they're bred to fight. The logical solution would be to quietly bump off (kill) all the Jem'Hader. But then that could mean a Jem'Hader revolt. As for shapeshifter attitudes to solids would they change? Not that much, I'd say they would be angry at solids, just because the 'solids' in the Alpha Quadrant kept the Dominion at bay.
|