do you think there's an aintimatter universe?

kirkkid7

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10164

Report this Dec. 01 2006, 7:50 am

well

lanceromega

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 3859

Report this Dec. 01 2006, 12:11 pm

Quote (kirkkid7 @ Nov. 30 2006, 8:50 am)
well

An alternate universe made of antimatter? fact is we are not even sure why our is composed mostly of matter. So it could be possible.

As it stand string theory predict a mirror universe like our own, but the different there would be due to parity making it compose of mirror or shadow matter, so it would not be antimatter..

Gerardus

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 341

Report this Dec. 09 2006, 5:04 am

Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 01 2006, 12:11 pm)
Quote (kirkkid7 @ Nov. 30 2006, 8:50 am)
well

An alternate universe made of antimatter? fact is we are not even sure why our is composed mostly of matter. So it could be possible.

As it stand string theory predict a mirror universe like our own, but the different there would be due to parity making it compose of mirror or shadow matter, so it would not be antimatter..

Somehow it has an existence of some sort. Consider dark energy which acts as a repellant force as opposed to gravity which attracts celestial objects hence you have orbits (Quantum Physics as mentioned by Einstein). Dark energy is still disputed but it gets some attention by scientists and some say it exists. I wonder if there is a device to measure antimatter. Please tell me.

lanceromega

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 3859

Report this Dec. 10 2006, 9:05 pm

Quote (Gerardus @ Dec. 08 2006, 6:04 am)
Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 01 2006, 12:11 pm)
Quote (kirkkid7 @ Nov. 30 2006, 8:50 am)
well

An alternate universe made of antimatter? fact is we are not even sure why our is composed mostly of matter. So it could be possible.

As it stand string theory predict a mirror universe like our own, but the different there would be due to parity making it compose of mirror or shadow matter, so it would not be antimatter..

Somehow it has an existence of some sort. Consider dark energy which acts as a repellant force as opposed to gravity which attracts celestial objects hence you have orbits (Quantum Physics as mentioned by Einstein). Dark energy is still disputed but it gets some attention by scientists and some say it exists. I wonder if there is a device to measure antimatter. Please tell me.

antimatter is detected by its reaction with normal matter, when particles of antimatter and matter combine we can detect the specific frequencies of gamma rays that are created.

By using Gamma ray detectors (mounted in obriting satellites) we have detected a fountain of antimatter ( positrons) being created by the giant blackhole in the center of our galaxy.

Other than that we can detect individual particles of antimatter by their behavior in particle detectors.

The original discovery of the Positron ( anti electron ) was by a cloud chamber that was observing cosmic rays, and it path in the magnetic field used to idenitied particle show it to be the same mass of a normal electron but possessing an opposite charge.

We know via gamma ray detectors that large amounts of antimatter is not common in the universe or if it is, there is some unknown process that keep it away from normal matter.

Captain_Ferguson

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 486

Report this Dec. 21 2006, 10:21 am

I suppose it is highly possible (thusly I said yes) for we now there are alternate dimensions where we exist as different things--cartoons, puppets, half-dog, half-human things.

lanceromega

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 3859

Report this Dec. 21 2006, 1:47 pm

Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 20 2006, 11:21 am)
I suppose it is highly possible (thusly I said yes) for we now there are alternate dimensions where we exist as different things--cartoons, puppets, half-dog, half-human things.

possible alternate dimensions? sound like a bad tv show..

As it stands dimensions are addition range of motion in  space, the 4 we normally deal with are three spacial ( left/right, up/down, fwd /backward) and time. Relativity add an additional where our 4 d space rest on call hyperspace, and string theory would add anywhere from 11 to 32 additional, with most of them be curl up so small that we cannot access them.

None of them would be the home of cat men, at best one could be the home of shadow or mirror matter, appearing very like our own but where the forces of electromagnetism, strong and weak force would not be felt and mirror forms of these forces exist.

Mirror matters would interact with gravity, forming a source of dark matter and on rare occasion a mirror photon and real photon will collide generating a super weak form of electromagnetism.

That why i doubt there is an antimatter dimension, since antimatter is just another form of normal matter, it absent in our universe is due to processes that favor the production of normal matter over it counterpart, these processes are mostly unknown, but weak forces is the one we do see.

the other may only come in play at the higher energies that existed shortly after the big bang and it hope that with the new generation of particle accelerator we will be discovering more of them and maybe glimpses of other dimensions.

kirkkid7

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10164

Report this Dec. 21 2006, 8:00 pm

bump

Captain_Ferguson

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 486

Report this Dec. 22 2006, 10:24 am

Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 20 2006, 4:47 pm)
Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 20 2006, 11:21 am)
I suppose it is highly possible (thusly I said yes) for we now there are alternate dimensions where we exist as different things--cartoons, puppets, half-dog, half-human things.

possible alternate dimensions? sound like a bad tv show..

As it stands dimensions are addition range of motion in ¿space, the 4 we normally deal with are three spacial ( left/right, up/down, fwd /backward) and time. Relativity add an additional where our 4 d space rest on call hyperspace, and string theory would add anywhere from 11 to 32 additional, with most of them be curl up so small that we cannot access them.

None of them would be the home of cat men, at best one could be the home of shadow or mirror matter, appearing very like our own but where the forces of electromagnetism, strong and weak force would not be felt and mirror forms of these forces exist.

Mirror matters would interact with gravity, forming a source of dark matter and on rare occasion a mirror photon and real photon will collide generating a super weak form of electromagnetism.

That why i doubt there is an antimatter dimension, since antimatter is just another form of normal matter, it absent in our universe is due to processes that favor the production of normal matter over it counterpart, these processes are mostly unknown, but weak forces is the one we do see.

the other may only come in play at the higher energies that existed shortly after the big bang and it hope that with the new generation of particle accelerator we will be discovering more of them and maybe glimpses of other dimensions.

Hey, im just citing what I read in a science magazine 3 or 4 years ago

lanceromega

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 3859

Report this Dec. 22 2006, 1:11 pm

Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 21 2006, 11:24 am)
Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 20 2006, 4:47 pm)
Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 20 2006, 11:21 am)
I suppose it is highly possible (thusly I said yes) for we now there are alternate dimensions where we exist as different things--cartoons, puppets, half-dog, half-human things.

possible alternate dimensions? sound like a bad tv show..

As it stands dimensions are addition range of motion in ?space, the 4 we normally deal with are three spacial ( left/right, up/down, fwd /backward) and time. Relativity add an additional where our 4 d space rest on call hyperspace, and string theory would add anywhere from 11 to 32 additional, with most of them be curl up so small that we cannot access them.

None of them would be the home of cat men, at best one could be the home of shadow or mirror matter, appearing very like our own but where the forces of electromagnetism, strong and weak force would not be felt and mirror forms of these forces exist.

Mirror matters would interact with gravity, forming a source of dark matter and on rare occasion a mirror photon and real photon will collide generating a super weak form of electromagnetism.

That why i doubt there is an antimatter dimension, since antimatter is just another form of normal matter, it absent in our universe is due to processes that favor the production of normal matter over it counterpart, these processes are mostly unknown, but weak forces is the one we do see.

the other may only come in play at the higher energies that existed shortly after the big bang and it hope that with the new generation of particle accelerator we will be discovering more of them and maybe glimpses of other dimensions.

Hey, im just citing what I read in a science magazine 3 or 4 years ago

There are science magazines and then there are "SCIENCE" magazines.

At best they are like all other magazines and attempt to snare reader with what popular and catchy..

Better to stick with Books, recent books like "Not Even wrong" and "What wrong with Physics" are taking a good look at the last 25 years romance with string theory and extra dimensions.
As it stand nothing really new has been discovered since most of physics has concertated on string theory.

There is little to no proof of even microscopic additional dimensions much less that ones large enought to house cat men or cartoon universes..

captain_jake_ramirez

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 35

Report this Dec. 27 2006, 4:35 pm

Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 22 2006, 1:11 pm)
Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 21 2006, 11:24 am)
Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 20 2006, 4:47 pm)
Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 20 2006, 11:21 am)
I suppose it is highly possible (thusly I said yes) for we now there are alternate dimensions where we exist as different things--cartoons, puppets, half-dog, half-human things.

possible alternate dimensions? sound like a bad tv show..

As it stands dimensions are addition range of motion in ?space, the 4 we normally deal with are three spacial ( left/right, up/down, fwd /backward) and time. Relativity add an additional where our 4 d space rest on call hyperspace, and string theory would add anywhere from 11 to 32 additional, with most of them be curl up so small that we cannot access them.

None of them would be the home of cat men, at best one could be the home of shadow or mirror matter, appearing very like our own but where the forces of electromagnetism, strong and weak force would not be felt and mirror forms of these forces exist.

Mirror matters would interact with gravity, forming a source of dark matter and on rare occasion a mirror photon and real photon will collide generating a super weak form of electromagnetism.

That why i doubt there is an antimatter dimension, since antimatter is just another form of normal matter, it absent in our universe is due to processes that favor the production of normal matter over it counterpart, these processes are mostly unknown, but weak forces is the one we do see.

the other may only come in play at the higher energies that existed shortly after the big bang and it hope that with the new generation of particle accelerator we will be discovering more of them and maybe glimpses of other dimensions.

Hey, im just citing what I read in a science magazine 3 or 4 years ago

There are science magazines and then there are "SCIENCE" magazines.

At best they are like all other magazines and attempt to snare reader with what popular and catchy..

Better to stick with Books, recent books like "Not Even wrong" and "What wrong with Physics" are taking a good look at the last 25 years romance with string theory and extra dimensions.
As it stand nothing really new has been discovered since most of physics has concertated on string theory.

There is little to no proof of even microscopic additional dimensions much less that ones large enought to house cat men or cartoon universes..

Hmm...I believe the term 'Dimension' is getting mistaken here.

Some people are using the term as in Alternate Realities and others are using it to describe Degrees of Freedom (Which has nothing to do with politics  :p ).

String theory pretty much says that an anti-matter universe is possible, especially with this crazy multiverse thing they're throwing around.

I agree with you 'anti-string theory', but you're making some pretty big claims there. Most scientific sources that are readily available are somewhat 'off'.

shanikhar

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 240

Report this Dec. 27 2006, 6:07 pm

:idea: Antimatter Universe would mean the anhilation of our Universe. This does not seem to be happening so the best guess is it doesn't occur.

captain_jake_ramirez

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 35

Report this Dec. 27 2006, 6:43 pm

Quote (shanikhar @ Dec. 27 2006, 6:07 pm)
:idea: Antimatter Universe would mean the anhilation of our Universe. This does not seem to be happening so the best guess is it doesn't occur.

Only if that universe was put on top of ours. If there was a multiverse that was in some other dimension, we'd be fine  :D

lanceromega

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 3859

Report this Dec. 28 2006, 11:05 am

Quote (captain_jake_ramirez @ Dec. 26 2006, 5:35 pm)
Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 22 2006, 1:11 pm)
Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 21 2006, 11:24 am)
Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 20 2006, 4:47 pm)
Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 20 2006, 11:21 am)
I suppose it is highly possible (thusly I said yes) for we now there are alternate dimensions where we exist as different things--cartoons, puppets, half-dog, half-human things.

possible alternate dimensions? sound like a bad tv show..

As it stands dimensions are addition range of motion in ?space, the 4 we normally deal with are three spacial ( left/right, up/down, fwd /backward) and time. Relativity add an additional where our 4 d space rest on call hyperspace, and string theory would add anywhere from 11 to 32 additional, with most of them be curl up so small that we cannot access them.

None of them would be the home of cat men, at best one could be the home of shadow or mirror matter, appearing very like our own but where the forces of electromagnetism, strong and weak force would not be felt and mirror forms of these forces exist.

Mirror matters would interact with gravity, forming a source of dark matter and on rare occasion a mirror photon and real photon will collide generating a super weak form of electromagnetism.

That why i doubt there is an antimatter dimension, since antimatter is just another form of normal matter, it absent in our universe is due to processes that favor the production of normal matter over it counterpart, these processes are mostly unknown, but weak forces is the one we do see.

the other may only come in play at the higher energies that existed shortly after the big bang and it hope that with the new generation of particle accelerator we will be discovering more of them and maybe glimpses of other dimensions.

Hey, im just citing what I read in a science magazine 3 or 4 years ago

There are science magazines and then there are "SCIENCE" magazines.

At best they are like all other magazines and attempt to snare reader with what popular and catchy..

Better to stick with Books, recent books like "Not Even wrong" and "What wrong with Physics" are taking a good look at the last 25 years romance with string theory and extra dimensions.
As it stand nothing really new has been discovered since most of physics has concertated on string theory.

There is little to no proof of even microscopic additional dimensions much less that ones large enought to house cat men or cartoon universes..

Hmm...I believe the term 'Dimension' is getting mistaken here.

Some people are using the term as in Alternate Realities and others are using it to describe Degrees of Freedom (Which has nothing to do with politics ?:p ).

String theory pretty much says that an anti-matter universe is possible, especially with this crazy multiverse thing they're throwing around.

I agree with you 'anti-string theory', but you're making some pretty big claims there. Most scientific sources that are readily available are somewhat 'off'.

It does?... As it goes string theory really doesn't say much! It has evolved to a point where it said that over 10 to the 50000 possible universes, it doesnot state if these universes actually exist now or ever existed, just that there is no one unique universe that could have emerge out of the big bang.

As for being mistaken, i using the scientific and mathematical definition of "Dimension", which is very different from parallel universes ( which all can exist in the same dimesions ) or parallel Branes ( which are multidimensional structures) that would exist if an additional spacial dimension exist that would seperate our brane from them.

degrees of freedom of motion is as close as you can get in layman terms when describing dimensions, now if we want to talk of antimatter universes that a different matter. ;)

captain_jake_ramirez

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 35

Report this Dec. 28 2006, 11:43 am

Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 28 2006, 11:05 am)
Quote (captain_jake_ramirez @ Dec. 26 2006, 5:35 pm)
Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 22 2006, 1:11 pm)
Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 21 2006, 11:24 am)
Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 20 2006, 4:47 pm)
Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 20 2006, 11:21 am)
I suppose it is highly possible (thusly I said yes) for we now there are alternate dimensions where we exist as different things--cartoons, puppets, half-dog, half-human things.

possible alternate dimensions? sound like a bad tv show..

As it stands dimensions are addition range of motion in ?space, the 4 we normally deal with are three spacial ( left/right, up/down, fwd /backward) and time. Relativity add an additional where our 4 d space rest on call hyperspace, and string theory would add anywhere from 11 to 32 additional, with most of them be curl up so small that we cannot access them.

None of them would be the home of cat men, at best one could be the home of shadow or mirror matter, appearing very like our own but where the forces of electromagnetism, strong and weak force would not be felt and mirror forms of these forces exist.

Mirror matters would interact with gravity, forming a source of dark matter and on rare occasion a mirror photon and real photon will collide generating a super weak form of electromagnetism.

That why i doubt there is an antimatter dimension, since antimatter is just another form of normal matter, it absent in our universe is due to processes that favor the production of normal matter over it counterpart, these processes are mostly unknown, but weak forces is the one we do see.

the other may only come in play at the higher energies that existed shortly after the big bang and it hope that with the new generation of particle accelerator we will be discovering more of them and maybe glimpses of other dimensions.

Hey, im just citing what I read in a science magazine 3 or 4 years ago

There are science magazines and then there are "SCIENCE" magazines.

At best they are like all other magazines and attempt to snare reader with what popular and catchy..

Better to stick with Books, recent books like "Not Even wrong" and "What wrong with Physics" are taking a good look at the last 25 years romance with string theory and extra dimensions.
As it stand nothing really new has been discovered since most of physics has concertated on string theory.

There is little to no proof of even microscopic additional dimensions much less that ones large enought to house cat men or cartoon universes..

Hmm...I believe the term 'Dimension' is getting mistaken here.

Some people are using the term as in Alternate Realities and others are using it to describe Degrees of Freedom (Which has nothing to do with politics ?:p ).

String theory pretty much says that an anti-matter universe is possible, especially with this crazy multiverse thing they're throwing around.

I agree with you 'anti-string theory', but you're making some pretty big claims there. Most scientific sources that are readily available are somewhat 'off'.

It does?... As it goes string theory really doesn't say much! It has evolved to a point where it said that over 10 to the 50000 possible universes, it doesnot state if these universes actually exist now or ever existed, just that there is no one unique universe that could have emerge out of the big bang.

As for being mistaken, i using the scientific and mathematical definition of "Dimension", which is very different from parallel universes ( which all can exist in the same dimesions ) or parallel Branes ( which are multidimensional structures) that would exist if an additional spacial dimension exist that would seperate our brane from them.

degrees of freedom of motion is as close as you can get in layman terms when describing dimensions, now if we want to talk of antimatter universes that a different matter. ;)

Well String theory is a vague ambigious area science. Last time I heard this Ed Witten came along and 'merged' all the different theories into one theory called M-theory, which isn't so problematic. It only needs two pieces of evidence to prove it exists; Gravitons and Sparticles (which also proves Supersymettry) (when I say prove, I mean it has some evidence to bring the theory into the possible regions of the theorhetical spectrum). This theory was made about 10 years ago, so I'm not too sure if it's still 'the' String Theory, but I believe it would be because CERN and Fermilab are still racing to find Gravitons and Sparticles.

Well, I never said people were mistaken here, I'm just stating that people are getting their nomenclature a bit mixed up here. The Term Dimension is an ambigious term which can mean degrees of freedom (in Mathmatics) and alternate universes. I think some people wrote alternate dimension and you started talking about the 'other' definition, it's just a plain misunderstanding, which happens all the bloody time over forums :p

http://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/gr/public/qg_ss.html

Good site here, I suggest you read it (or at least the part about dimensions), helped me understand the absolute basics  :p

I believe the thread was made to talk about the idea of an anti-matter universe, nothing about extra dimensions.

lanceromega

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 3859

Report this Dec. 28 2006, 2:26 pm

Quote (captain_jake_ramirez @ Dec. 27 2006, 12:43 pm)
Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 28 2006, 11:05 am)
Quote (captain_jake_ramirez @ Dec. 26 2006, 5:35 pm)
Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 22 2006, 1:11 pm)
Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 21 2006, 11:24 am)
Quote (lanceromega @ Dec. 20 2006, 4:47 pm)
Quote (Captain_Ferguson @ Dec. 20 2006, 11:21 am)
I suppose it is highly possible (thusly I said yes) for we now there are alternate dimensions where we exist as different things--cartoons, puppets, half-dog, half-human things.

possible alternate dimensions? sound like a bad tv show..

As it stands dimensions are addition range of motion in ?space, the 4 we normally deal with are three spacial ( left/right, up/down, fwd /backward) and time. Relativity add an additional where our 4 d space rest on call hyperspace, and string theory would add anywhere from 11 to 32 additional, with most of them be curl up so small that we cannot access them.

None of them would be the home of cat men, at best one could be the home of shadow or mirror matter, appearing very like our own but where the forces of electromagnetism, strong and weak force would not be felt and mirror forms of these forces exist.

Mirror matters would interact with gravity, forming a source of dark matter and on rare occasion a mirror photon and real photon will collide generating a super weak form of electromagnetism.

That why i doubt there is an antimatter dimension, since antimatter is just another form of normal matter, it absent in our universe is due to processes that favor the production of normal matter over it counterpart, these processes are mostly unknown, but weak forces is the one we do see.

the other may only come in play at the higher energies that existed shortly after the big bang and it hope that with the new generation of particle accelerator we will be discovering more of them and maybe glimpses of other dimensions.

Hey, im just citing what I read in a science magazine 3 or 4 years ago

There are science magazines and then there are "SCIENCE" magazines.

At best they are like all other magazines and attempt to snare reader with what popular and catchy..

Better to stick with Books, recent books like "Not Even wrong" and "What wrong with Physics" are taking a good look at the last 25 years romance with string theory and extra dimensions.
As it stand nothing really new has been discovered since most of physics has concertated on string theory.

There is little to no proof of even microscopic additional dimensions much less that ones large enought to house cat men or cartoon universes..

Hmm...I believe the term 'Dimension' is getting mistaken here.

Some people are using the term as in Alternate Realities and others are using it to describe Degrees of Freedom (Which has nothing to do with politics ?:p ).

String theory pretty much says that an anti-matter universe is possible, especially with this crazy multiverse thing they're throwing around.

I agree with you 'anti-string theory', but you're making some pretty big claims there. Most scientific sources that are readily available are somewhat 'off'.

It does?... As it goes string theory really doesn't say much! It has evolved to a point where it said that over 10 to the 50000 possible universes, it doesnot state if these universes actually exist now or ever existed, just that there is no one unique universe that could have emerge out of the big bang.

As for being mistaken, i using the scientific and mathematical definition of "Dimension", which is very different from parallel universes ( which all can exist in the same dimesions ) or parallel Branes ( which are multidimensional structures) that would exist if an additional spacial dimension exist that would seperate our brane from them.

degrees of freedom of motion is as close as you can get in layman terms when describing dimensions, now if we want to talk of antimatter universes that a different matter. ;)

Well String theory is a vague ambigious area science. Last time I heard this Ed Witten came along and 'merged' all the different theories into one theory called M-theory, which isn't so problematic. It only needs two pieces of evidence to prove it exists; Gravitons and Sparticles (which also proves Supersymettry) (when I say prove, I mean it has some evidence to bring the theory into the possible regions of the theorhetical spectrum). This theory was made about 10 years ago, so I'm not too sure if it's still 'the' String Theory, but I believe it would be because CERN and Fermilab are still racing to find Gravitons and Sparticles.

Well, I never said people were mistaken here, I'm just stating that people are getting their nomenclature a bit mixed up here. The Term Dimension is an ambigious term which can mean degrees of freedom (in Mathmatics) and alternate universes. I think some people wrote alternate dimension and you started talking about the 'other' definition, it's just a plain misunderstanding, which happens all the bloody time over forums :p

http://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/gr/public/qg_ss.html

Good site here, I suggest you read it (or at least the part about dimensions), helped me understand the absolute basics ¿:p

I believe the thread was made to talk about the idea of an anti-matter universe, nothing about extra dimensions.

actually M theory makes it more so, original string theory introduct about 50 random constants. M theory raised this to around 100.

Basically M theory states all of the different string theories and SUSY theory are just different views of the same master theory, what this matter theory is dependents on the number of holes or manifolds a single point of space possess.

What Witten did not state is how many holes are there for our universe, what determines this factor or set the value of the other constants that M theory would depend on.

For the last 10 years scientist have conducted 1000's of experiments, search cloud chambers, and stared at distant Quasars to find a hint  that even one of these extra dimensions that string theory predict exist.. No evident in the least, on top of that it has failed to predict dark energy ( which Einstein did in General relativity) or account for several of the surprises that have sprung up in the field of particle physics...As many physicist have comment of late, we have made no major advance in the last 25 years since string theory has reared it eleghant yet ugly head..

As for your link, i believe i understand string and m theory just fine.. thanks anyway.

As for the antimatter universe, since we donot why antimatter is not plentiful in our own, and since there is no hint of other universes, it doubtful that another universe filled with antimatter exist, especially in the light that there is no place for it to exist if other dimensions donot. For multiuniverses to exist there would need to be a seperate larger spacial dimension to place them all in.

Recently logged in

Users browsing this forum: willowtree, bunkey, FleetAdmiral_BamBam, Simon Bridgewater

Forum Permissions

You cannot post new topics in this forum

You cannot reply to topics in this forum

You cannot delete posts in this forum