ATTENTION: The Boards will be closed permanently on May 28th, 2014. Posting will be disabled on April 28th, 2014. More Info

Episode discussions and ratings

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Sep. 30 2006, 4:20 am

I'm doing a weekly episode poll. You can use the links to access the polls & vote. A little request before you visit the polls: Please don't bump up a lot of polls at once just by writing short responses like "I give it a 7". Write why you give the episode this rating/ share some trivia & backround information/ ask a question or share your thoughts on some details. You can also vote without posting. I update the old polls regulary, it doesn't depend on which page they are. (This is just to protect the board from being flooded.)



Voyager Season Overview


* * * * * * * Season 1 (7.44 points season average)

* * * * * * * Caretaker (7.30 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * * * Parallax (7.29 points, 17.5.07)
Time and Again
* * * * * Prime Factors (5.86 points, 2.6.07)
* * * * * * * * State of Flux (8.57 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * * * * Cathexis (8.33 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * * * Faces (7.19 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * * * Learning Curve (7.70 points, 14.8.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * Season 2 (6.29 points season average)

* * * * * * * Persistance of Vision (7.09 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * Tattoo (5.14 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * Cold Fire (6.05 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * Prototype (6.71 points, 20.8.07)
* * Treshold (2.34 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * * Death Wish (7.95 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * Lifesigns (6.16 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * * * Basics (8.91 points, 7.7.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * * Season 3 (7.50 points season average)

* * * * * * * * Basics (8.91 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * * * * * Future's End (8.40 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * * Warlord (5.64 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * * * * The Q and the Grey (7.72 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * Favorite Son (4.63 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * * * * * Worst Case Scenario (8.08 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * * * * * Scorpion  (8.22 points, 7.7.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * * Season 4 (7.33 points season average)

* * * * * * * * Scorpion (8.20 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * * Day of Honor (7.26 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * * * Concerning Flight (8.00 points, 17.6.07)
* * * * * * * * Waking Moments (8.27 points, 5.8.07)
* * * * * * * Prey (7.03 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * Vis a Vis (5.22 points, 24.5.07)
* * * * * * * Living Witness (7.63 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * * One (7.03 points, 1.5.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * Season 5 (6.83 points season average)

* * * * * * * * Extreme Risk (8.26 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * * * Infinite Regress (8.77 points, 21.7.07)
* * * * * * * Latent Image (7.27 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * * Gravity (7.00 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * Bliss (6.28 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * 11:59 (4.15 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * * * Relativity (8.35 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * Warhead (4.63 points, 2.7.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * Season 6 (6.13 points season average)

* * * * * * * * * Tinker, Tenor, Doctor, Spy  (9.50 points, 15.7.07)
* * * * * Dragon's Teeth  (5.24 points, 11.5.07)
* * * * * * * Blink of an Eye (7.55 points, 11.5.07)
* * * * * * Collective (6.60 points, 26.8.07)
* * * * * Ashes to Ashes (5.89 points, 11.5.07)
* * * * * * Good Shepherd (6.06 points, 11.5.07)
* * * * * Muse  (5.30 points, 9.6.07)
* * * Fury (3.37 points, 11.5.07)
* * * * * Life Line (5.68 points, 9.6.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * Season 7 (6.00 points season average)

* * * * * * Imperfection (6.00 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * * Critical Care (6.51 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * Inside Man (5.75 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * Flesh and Blood (5.73 points, 23.6.07)
* * * * * * Prophecy (6.81 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * Endgame (5.74 points, 17.5.07)
to be completed

=========================================

VOY-charts
(last update: 19.5.07)


* * * * * * * * * Outstanding
9.75-10.00 points
-
9.50-9.75 points
-
9.25-9.50 points
-
9.00-9.25 points
-


* * * * * * * * Everything well done
8.75-9.00 points
-
8.50-8.75 points
State of Flux
Future's End
8.25-8.50 points
Relativity
Cathexis
Extreme Risk
8.00-8.25 points
Scorpion
Worst Case Scenario


* * * * * * * Very enjoyable with minor flaws
7.75-8.00 points
Death Wish
7.50-7.75 points
The Q and the Grey
Living Witness
Blink of an Eye
7.25-7.50 points
Caretaker
Parallax
Day of Honor
Latent Image
7.00-7.25 points
Faces
Persistance of Vision
Prey
One
Gravity


* * * * * * Nice Entertainment
6.75-7.00 points
Prophecy
6.50-6.75 points
Critical Care
6.25-6.50 points
Bliss
6.00-6.25 points
Life Signs
Good Shepherd
Cold Fire
Warlord
Imperfection


* * * * * Okay, but not memorable
5.75-6.00 points
Ashes to Ashes
Inside Man
5.50-5.75 points
Endgame
5.25-5.50 points
Favorite Son
5.00-5.25 points
Dragon's Teeth
Tattoo


* * * * Many flaws, but still watchable
4.57-5.00 points
Life Line
4.50-4.75 points
-
4.25-4.50 points
-
4.00-4.25 points
11:59


* * * Disappointing, but a few good moments
3.57-4.00 points
-
3.50-3.75 points
-
3.25-3.50 points
Fury
3.00-3.25 points
-


* * Crap
2.75-3.00 points
-
2.50-2.75 points
-
2.25-2.50 points
Treshold
2.00-2.25 points
-


* Insane
1.75-2.00 points
-
1.50-1.75 points
-
1.25-1.50 points
-
1.00-1.25 points
-


Completly awful!
0.75-1.00 points
-
0.50-0.75 points
-
0.25-0.50 points
-
0.00-0.25 points
-

========================================

Here's the rating system (feel free to copy for polls not made yet):
My favorite Star Trek-episode
My favorite VOY-episode
10  Great, an amazing episode
9  Everything well done
7  Enjoyable with minor flaws
5  Okay, but not memorable
3  Disappointing, but a few good moments
0  Completly awful
Worst VOY-episode ever seen
Worst Star Trek-episode ever seen  

==========================================

General overview
See also TOS ratings
See also TNG ratings
See also DS9 ratings


Thanks to following poll makers:
CourtneyDax
SamusAranX
DATA2OO7

cosmo930

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 594

Report this Oct. 01 2006, 1:42 am

I have cast my votes, the rest is history
                                                         cheers , cosmo

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Oct. 07 2006, 9:12 am

Updated.

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Oct. 14 2006, 8:46 am

Updated.

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Oct. 22 2006, 5:35 am

Updated.

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Oct. 28 2006, 5:00 am

Updated.

cosmo930

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 594

Report this Nov. 03 2006, 3:55 am

OST & STNG are the best, followed by Voyager with Dipshiite9 next, Enterprise a poor last.
                               cosmo

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Nov. 04 2006, 10:15 am

Updated.

kirkkid7

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10164

Report this Nov. 04 2006, 10:17 am

updated?

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Nov. 04 2006, 10:22 am

I calculated the average of the rated episode and added it to the overview above. I also need to constantly bump this thread so it can serve as link-system and information page.

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Nov. 12 2006, 1:13 pm

Updated: Caretaker, Tattoo
New episode: Scorpion

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Nov. 19 2006, 5:08 am

Updated:
11:59 (new)
Scorpion (new outcomes)

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Nov. 26 2006, 4:21 pm

Updated:
11:59 (new outcomes)
Prey (new poll)
Scorpion -

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Dec. 02 2006, 9:08 am

Updated:
Prey (new outcomes) -> season 4 average - *
Lifesigns (new poll)
charts

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Dec. 09 2006, 11:39 am

Updated:

Lifesigns (new outcomes) -> season 2 average + *
Worst Case Scenario (new poll)

Scorpion (-)
Prey (-)
-> season 3 and season 4 averages (-)


I don't display the fav. and worst-percentages because it looks a bit confusing on the overview any longer, you can see them if you use the episode links.

Forum Permissions

You cannot post new topics in this forum

You cannot reply to topics in this forum

You cannot delete posts in this forum