ATTENTION: The Boards will be closed permanently on May 28th, 2014. Posting will be disabled on April 28th, 2014. More Info

Episode discussions and ratings

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Sep. 30 2006, 4:20 am

I'm doing a weekly episode poll. You can use the links to access the polls & vote. A little request before you visit the polls: Please don't bump up a lot of polls at once just by writing short responses like "I give it a 7". Write why you give the episode this rating/ share some trivia & backround information/ ask a question or share your thoughts on some details. You can also vote without posting. I update the old polls regulary, it doesn't depend on which page they are. (This is just to protect the board from being flooded.)



Voyager Season Overview


* * * * * * * Season 1 (7.44 points season average)

* * * * * * * Caretaker (7.30 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * * * Parallax (7.29 points, 17.5.07)
Time and Again
* * * * * Prime Factors (5.86 points, 2.6.07)
* * * * * * * * State of Flux (8.57 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * * * * Cathexis (8.33 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * * * Faces (7.19 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * * * Learning Curve (7.70 points, 14.8.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * Season 2 (6.29 points season average)

* * * * * * * Persistance of Vision (7.09 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * Tattoo (5.14 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * Cold Fire (6.05 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * Prototype (6.71 points, 20.8.07)
* * Treshold (2.34 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * * Death Wish (7.95 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * Lifesigns (6.16 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * * * Basics (8.91 points, 7.7.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * * Season 3 (7.50 points season average)

* * * * * * * * Basics (8.91 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * * * * * Future's End (8.40 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * * Warlord (5.64 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * * * * The Q and the Grey (7.72 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * Favorite Son (4.63 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * * * * * Worst Case Scenario (8.08 points, 7.7.07)
* * * * * * * * Scorpion  (8.22 points, 7.7.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * * Season 4 (7.33 points season average)

* * * * * * * * Scorpion (8.20 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * * Day of Honor (7.26 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * * * Concerning Flight (8.00 points, 17.6.07)
* * * * * * * * Waking Moments (8.27 points, 5.8.07)
* * * * * * * Prey (7.03 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * Vis a Vis (5.22 points, 24.5.07)
* * * * * * * Living Witness (7.63 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * * One (7.03 points, 1.5.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * Season 5 (6.83 points season average)

* * * * * * * * Extreme Risk (8.26 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * * * Infinite Regress (8.77 points, 21.7.07)
* * * * * * * Latent Image (7.27 points, 19.5.07)
* * * * * * * Gravity (7.00 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * Bliss (6.28 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * 11:59 (4.15 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * * * * * Relativity (8.35 points, 1.5.07)
* * * * Warhead (4.63 points, 2.7.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * Season 6 (6.13 points season average)

* * * * * * * * * Tinker, Tenor, Doctor, Spy  (9.50 points, 15.7.07)
* * * * * Dragon's Teeth  (5.24 points, 11.5.07)
* * * * * * * Blink of an Eye (7.55 points, 11.5.07)
* * * * * * Collective (6.60 points, 26.8.07)
* * * * * Ashes to Ashes (5.89 points, 11.5.07)
* * * * * * Good Shepherd (6.06 points, 11.5.07)
* * * * * Muse  (5.30 points, 9.6.07)
* * * Fury (3.37 points, 11.5.07)
* * * * * Life Line (5.68 points, 9.6.07)
to be completed


* * * * * * Season 7 (6.00 points season average)

* * * * * * Imperfection (6.00 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * * Critical Care (6.51 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * Inside Man (5.75 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * Flesh and Blood (5.73 points, 23.6.07)
* * * * * * Prophecy (6.81 points, 17.5.07)
* * * * * Endgame (5.74 points, 17.5.07)
to be completed

=========================================

VOY-charts
(last update: 19.5.07)


* * * * * * * * * Outstanding
9.75-10.00 points
-
9.50-9.75 points
-
9.25-9.50 points
-
9.00-9.25 points
-


* * * * * * * * Everything well done
8.75-9.00 points
-
8.50-8.75 points
State of Flux
Future's End
8.25-8.50 points
Relativity
Cathexis
Extreme Risk
8.00-8.25 points
Scorpion
Worst Case Scenario


* * * * * * * Very enjoyable with minor flaws
7.75-8.00 points
Death Wish
7.50-7.75 points
The Q and the Grey
Living Witness
Blink of an Eye
7.25-7.50 points
Caretaker
Parallax
Day of Honor
Latent Image
7.00-7.25 points
Faces
Persistance of Vision
Prey
One
Gravity


* * * * * * Nice Entertainment
6.75-7.00 points
Prophecy
6.50-6.75 points
Critical Care
6.25-6.50 points
Bliss
6.00-6.25 points
Life Signs
Good Shepherd
Cold Fire
Warlord
Imperfection


* * * * * Okay, but not memorable
5.75-6.00 points
Ashes to Ashes
Inside Man
5.50-5.75 points
Endgame
5.25-5.50 points
Favorite Son
5.00-5.25 points
Dragon's Teeth
Tattoo


* * * * Many flaws, but still watchable
4.57-5.00 points
Life Line
4.50-4.75 points
-
4.25-4.50 points
-
4.00-4.25 points
11:59


* * * Disappointing, but a few good moments
3.57-4.00 points
-
3.50-3.75 points
-
3.25-3.50 points
Fury
3.00-3.25 points
-


* * Crap
2.75-3.00 points
-
2.50-2.75 points
-
2.25-2.50 points
Treshold
2.00-2.25 points
-


* Insane
1.75-2.00 points
-
1.50-1.75 points
-
1.25-1.50 points
-
1.00-1.25 points
-


Completly awful!
0.75-1.00 points
-
0.50-0.75 points
-
0.25-0.50 points
-
0.00-0.25 points
-

========================================

Here's the rating system (feel free to copy for polls not made yet):
My favorite Star Trek-episode
My favorite VOY-episode
10  Great, an amazing episode
9  Everything well done
7  Enjoyable with minor flaws
5  Okay, but not memorable
3  Disappointing, but a few good moments
0  Completly awful
Worst VOY-episode ever seen
Worst Star Trek-episode ever seen  

==========================================

General overview
See also TOS ratings
See also TNG ratings
See also DS9 ratings


Thanks to following poll makers:
CourtneyDax
SamusAranX
DATA2OO7

cosmo930

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 594

Report this Oct. 01 2006, 1:42 am

I have cast my votes, the rest is history
                                                         cheers , cosmo

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Oct. 07 2006, 9:12 am

Updated.

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Oct. 14 2006, 8:46 am

Updated.

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Oct. 22 2006, 5:35 am

Updated.

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Oct. 28 2006, 5:00 am

Updated.

cosmo930

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 594

Report this Nov. 03 2006, 3:55 am

OST & STNG are the best, followed by Voyager with Dipshiite9 next, Enterprise a poor last.
                               cosmo

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Nov. 04 2006, 10:15 am

Updated.

kirkkid7

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10164

Report this Nov. 04 2006, 10:17 am

updated?

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Nov. 04 2006, 10:22 am

I calculated the average of the rated episode and added it to the overview above. I also need to constantly bump this thread so it can serve as link-system and information page.

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Nov. 12 2006, 1:13 pm

Updated: Caretaker, Tattoo
New episode: Scorpion

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Nov. 19 2006, 5:08 am

Updated:
11:59 (new)
Scorpion (new outcomes)

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Nov. 26 2006, 4:21 pm

Updated:
11:59 (new outcomes)
Prey (new poll)
Scorpion -

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Dec. 02 2006, 9:08 am

Updated:
Prey (new outcomes) -> season 4 average - *
Lifesigns (new poll)
charts

Passionfruit

GROUP: Members

POSTS: 10184

Report this Dec. 09 2006, 11:39 am

Updated:

Lifesigns (new outcomes) -> season 2 average + *
Worst Case Scenario (new poll)

Scorpion (-)
Prey (-)
-> season 3 and season 4 averages (-)


I don't display the fav. and worst-percentages because it looks a bit confusing on the overview any longer, you can see them if you use the episode links.

Recently logged in

Users browsing this forum: miklamar, FleetAdmiral_BamBam

Forum Permissions

You cannot post new topics in this forum

You cannot reply to topics in this forum

You cannot delete posts in this forum